The Daily Signal
Film

Stop Waiting for Festivals to Tell You What to Watch

Felix·Friday, September 25, 2026 Edition
When taste becomes ornamental

Fantastic Fest's 2026 lineup. Pathetic Fallacy with Kid Cudi, the Spanish vampire film Upiro, the Australian thriller Kick On, and What Happened to Doris? — represents exactly the kind of curation that used to matter. These are films that require taste to program, the sort of selection that once proved a festival's judgment to distributors watching from Los Angeles.

That system has inverted. Fantastic Fest still knows what it's doing. The problem is that knowing what you're doing has stopped being the thing that gets films to their actual audience.

Fifteen years ago, a Fantastic Fest premiere functioned as a distribution signal. Studios sent scouts. If a film played well in Austin, it would get picked up for theatrical release, and that theatrical release meant it entered the machinery of discovery. Word of mouth, reviews, word-of-mouth again. The festival's taste became a market prediction. Fantastic Fest said "people like this" and then those people actually found it, in movie theaters. There was nowhere else it could go.

The curation that curates nobody

Then streaming platforms became the distribution mechanism. Netflix, Amazon, and a dozen smaller services now release genre films directly to algorithms. Those algorithms don't go to Austin. They don't watch four films back to back and make a judgment. They track watch time and skip rate and autoplay completion. They put films in front of people based on what they already watched last Tuesday. The curation that happens at Fantastic Fest. The human selection that says "these four films deserve attention together" — is now completely decoupled from reach. The festival is selecting for the 2,000 people in the theater, not the 200,000 who might actually want these films if they knew to look. Fantastic Fest became a wine tasting for people who already drink wine, which means it still drinks wine perfectly well. Reaches almost nobody new.

Key Facts
*Festival programming once signaled which films would get U.S. distribution deals and find their audience
*Streaming platforms now use algorithms rather than curators to match viewers with genre films
*Fantastic Fest's judgment matters less to reach than to validation among already-engaged fans
Related Stories
Insight
That Form Has No Box for Contempt
Anger doesn't end relationships — contempt does. Understanding the difference between expressing a need and signaling that your partner is beneath you changes w…
Culture
Streep's Miranda Priestly Rewrote Fashion Editors Into Her Image
When actors claim to build characters from real people they've observed, audiences mistake specificity for documentary truth—but the performance often becomes t…
Technology
Brad Smith takes communications — what Microsoft stops saying
Microsoft moved communications reporting from marketing into its legal and regulatory affairs division, signaling that the company now treats its public voice a…
View Past Editions >