We are paying for tools that make us forget how to think.
A bookmark manager promises you will never lose what matters. A language model runs faster on your machine. A social platform keeps you engaged. None of these are neutral tools — they are architectures designed to solve a problem you didn't know you had, which means they are solving the problem they created. The real mechanism is simpler than it looks: something that makes your life easier by making your mind smaller.
Convenience redistributes your attention from your own priorities to someone else's design. When Linkflare saves your links and Meta optimizes their models for your hardware, the tool becomes the filter between you and what you meant to do with your time.
2
The trap is that the problem and the solution arrive together, packaged as progress. A child learns language from a human face, not a screen, but the screen solves the immediate problem of keeping them quiet. Meta's Muse Spark runs beautifully on your Mac, but it runs on their terms.
3
The people most vulnerable to this are the ones already paying attention, already trying to think clearly. A thoughtful person who wants to remember everything is exactly the person who will install a tool to manage memory, which means they stop trusting their own mind and start trusting the interface.