Everyone is rebranding their actual problem as something else.
When Urbansky built a tool to stop people from forgetting what matters, he diagnosed a real crisis of attention. When nicotine repackaged itself as wellness, it named the same problem from the opposite direction—not that we forget, but that we need permission to do what we already want. Both are solutions looking for moral cover.
We have stopped trusting our own choices, so we now require external systems—tools, wellness frames, expert curation—to legitimize what we were already going to do anyway.
2
Nicotine pouches work because they let the user believe they have transcended the addiction by transcending the tobacco, the same way a bookmark manager lets us believe we have transcended forgetfulness by transcending the chaos. Tesla's Optimus struggles because it cannot rebrand manufacturing reality as something other than what it is—the constraint stays visible.
3
What scales fastest is not what works best but what successfully separates the user from shame about their own behavior, which means the next five years will belong to whoever can make ordinary wants feel intentional.