Everything profitable now eats its own source material.
The lawsuits against Anthropic aren't about theft. They're about a system that treats creative work as raw material to be consumed at scale, leaving nothing for what comes next. Katseye burns through members and goodwill faster than they can replenish it. Geralt returns because the original work still holds value that can be milked, not because there's new ground to break.
Markets optimize for what's already proven, which means they extract maximum value from it until it collapses, then move to the next proven thing rather than funding the uncertain work that would replenish it.
2
Katseye's toxic fandom and dwindling membership reveal what happens when you're built as a product for existing appetites instead of as something that creates its own culture. Anthropic's training on copyrighted work follows the same logic: use what worked to scale what's profitable, ignore the question of whether you're leaving room for the next generation of creators.
3
The machine that made The Witcher 3 valuable will eventually kill the conditions that made making it possible. When every new work is trained on the last, when every new band is optimized for existing fan behavior, when every dollar goes to the proven hit instead of the unproven voice, we don't get innovation. We get recursion.